UPDATE: Top Arun councillors face calls to resign over ‘spectacular failure’ of local plan

Ricky Bower, cabinet member for planning and infrastructure, faces calls to resign this morning alongside leader Gill Brown
Ricky Bower, cabinet member for planning and infrastructure, faces calls to resign this morning alongside leader Gill Brown

Senior Arun councillors face calls to resign this morning from more than 150 residents dismayed by what they say is the ‘spectacular failure’ of the district’s local plan.

An open letter signed by 159 residents urges Arun District Council leader Gill Brown and cabinet member for planning and infrastructure Ricky Bower to step down.

The letter follows the likely suspension of the local plan for up to 18 months – a lengthy delay required for further work on updated housing targets.

The letter reads: “The council has been invited by the inspector to suspend the local plan for a period of 12­-18 months in order to bring forward modifications. This constitutes the spectacular failure of a plan, over nine years in the making, and still a long way from completion.”

In response, Mr Bower said the inspector had not found the plan ‘unsound’ but ‘basically incomplete’, while officers and members were still digesting the ramifications of his recommendations.

He added the council approved the submission of the plan last September by recorded vote, with 37 out of the 56 councillors in favour, 12 abstaining and two against. Mr Bower said: “I’m not going to respond with a knee-jerk reaction to this letter. I like things to be seen through and I am going to see it through.”

The local plan sets out the district’s vision for housing and employment until 2031.

It sets a target for the number of homes which should be built each year – a figure known as ‘objectively assessed needs’ (OAN).

Arun’s plan set a target of 580 homes per year, a figure it raised to 641 in June after new statistics emerged. It wanted to suspend the plan for six months, in order to commission further work on the updated numbers.

But after the plan was submitted, yet another set of statistics were released by the Government, setting the actual number at more than 750 homes per year. The council decided against working towards the 758 figure – despite accepting this was the latest data at a recent planning appeal.

Discussing the issue at a series of public hearings in June, critics of the plan argued this meant it was legally unsound.

Following the hearings, inspector Roy Foster wrote to the council last Wednesday, advising it suspended the plan for up to 18 months.

He advised the authority to work towards the 758 homes per year target.

The local plan sub-committee agreed to recommend the suspension to full council at a meeting on Thursday.

Mrs Brown said the council had ‘every confidence’ the plan would have met the inspector’s approval.

She said: “It is highly unfortunate that our journey towards plan adoption has been blown off course by the council having to respond to the latest household projections from the Office of National Statistics.

“We are obviously disappointed with this outcome that the local plan now has to accommodate a much higher level of housing provision, but we need to respect the inspector’s conclusions.”

Arun Liberal Democrats have criticised the handling of the matter as a ‘shambles’.

Deputy leader Dr James Walsh said he supported the residents and the reasons given for the resignation calls.

He said: “By their lengthy procrastination over this matter over the last five years, Arun’s Tory leadership has left us in the worst possible position. We have no adopted local plan, and it now may take months, or longer, to get one.”

Arun Lib Dem leader Francis Oppler, meanwhile, said the duo should take ‘complete responsibility’ for the situation.

The open letter in full:

“We are concerned that Arun District Council is failing to provide an acceptable level of service when it comes to strategic planning and that it also lacks the leadership capability necessary to secure improvements.

The council has been “invited” by the inspector to suspend the local plan for a period of 12­-18 months in order to bring forward modifications. This constitutes the spectacular failure of a plan, over nine years in the making, and still a long way from completion. This is on top of the recent failure of the St Modwen proposals for Bognor Regis.

It has been estimated that something in the region of £2.7 million may have been spent (wasted?) so far on these two failed projects. This is unacceptable.

Through its actions and continual delays, the council has created circumstances in which every community in the district is now vulnerable to planning by appeal.

It is time for those responsible to be held to account for their part in this failure of strategic planning.

We call on cllr Mrs Brown, The leader of the council and cabinet member for council strategy and cllr Bower, cabinet member for planning and infrastructure, both of whom have held their respective offices for over nine years, to resign with immediate effect, in order to allow new leaders to come forward and initiate a fresh start for the district.”

Yours sincerely,

Val Allison

Alan Allison

Jon Alward

Jessica Arnold

Nicky Baker

Dougie Baker

Laurie Barnes

Alison Barnham

Sylvia Belcher

Vanessa Bentley

Dominic Bentley

Jeff Berman

Natalie Blissett

Helen Bowles

Eileen Bradbury

Jess Brown

Darrel Burch

Danii Campbell

Helen Cann

Jon Cann

Jason Castle

Ashleigh Charmaine

Robert Clark

Olive Clark

Peter Coleman

Sue Coleman

Lisa Collier

Martin Connelly

Dorothy Constant

Peter Constant

Jo Corell

Gerald Cork

Hugh Coster

Anthony Cross

Jim Darley

Brian Davey

Danny Dawes

Sharon Demers

Laura Denby

Tony Dixon

Alane Dixon

Catherine Dummer

Terry Ellis

Sarah Evans

Dez Farley

Gary Fisk

Lily Fraser

Carol Freeth

Caroline Gibbons

David Gould

Tracey Grattan

Wendy Green

Linda Guy

Audrey Hall

Deborah Hallford

Mary Harvey

Mike Harvey

Mary Herting

Kerry Hills

Simon Home

Danni Hooper

Lee Hooper

J Hopgood

Jacqueline Howard

Denise Jays

Helen Johnson

Dominic Jones

Melanie Jones

Adele Jones

Brigitte Jones

Mike Jupp

Trisha Keegan

Ben Keen

Peter Keen

Chris Kelly

Ren Kitchener

Graham Knight

Jess Knowles

James Lambert

David Lancaster

Lynn Laundon

Tracey Light

Sue Ludlam

Lesley Marsh

Alvin Martinez

Wendy Matthey

Bobbi McBride

Robin McDonald

Jamie Middleton

Helen Miles

Melanie Miller

Simon Mitchell

Tessa Moger

Joanne Moon

Helen Moore

Julie Muir

Ben Mulrooney

Jenny Murphy

Kevin Murphy

Luke Nash

Jon New

Steve Nicholas

Bradley Nicholas

Rose OBrien

Nicola Page

Ian Pears

Danielle Pearson

Lesley Pedwell

David Pedwell

Ian Pedwell

John Penfold

Heather Penfold

Mandy Phillips

Zoe Prior

Mike Purdue

Ann Rapnik

Kerry Redman

Lorraine Ritchie

Gabriella Robinson

Charlotte Robinson

Rita Rogers-Davis

Neil Rogers-Davis

Tracey Salford

Kaye Sawyer

David Sawyer

Sue Sayer

Nicole Scott-Cannon

Jane Searle

Tracey Simpkins

Simone Sinclair

Christopher Sinclair

Margaret Smart

Fred Smart

Nigel Smith

Catherine Southern

Brian Sullivan

Liz Sullivan

Tony Sutcliffe

Elizabeth Swain

Annmarie Taylor

Eileen Taylor

John Taylor

Ken Teasdale

Roger Thomas

Troy Turner

Rosie-Mae Turner-Hughes

Caroline Varatharasan

Alec Wallsgrove

Sue Wallsgrove

Emma West

Suzie Wheller

Susan White

Katie Wilbraham

Richard Wilkins

Janet Wilkins

Maryann Williams

Sarah Williams

Shelley Wingate

Mervyn Woodruff

*Don’t miss out on all the latest breaking news where you live.

Here are four ways you can be sure you’ll be amongst the first to know what’s going on.

1) Make our website your homepage

2) Like our Facebook page

3) Follow us on Twitter

4) Register with us by clicking on ‘sign in’ (top right corner). You can then receive our daily newsletter AND add your point of view to stories that you read here.

And do share with your family and friends - so they don’t miss out!

Always the first with your local news.

Be part of it.